Let me know which dress you like best!
OPTION #1: Vogue Dress: Badgley Mischka
First of all let's talk about the fact that it is a Badgley Mischka design. That, in and of itself, is enough of a reason to make this dress! I think this is a gorgeous dress, but I am uncertain of where I would have to wear it. The only change I would make on this dress is probably to bring the bust together so it is a little less low cut: a little less "J-Lo", if you know what I mean. And I don't know what colour I would make it in either.
OPTION #2: McCalls Dress
This one is going to need a little more imagination on your part. My idea is to make the dress out of a really beautiful fabric like a dupioni silk or a silk faille (trust me - very nice, and structured) and then add a layer of lace over the bodice of the dress (top half). Then perhaps I would add a lace trim along the bottom of the skirt. Version A is the one I would make, but it has the entire dress with a lace overlay - I would probably just do the top half. Or perhaps I would add version C's sleeves. How beautiful would a textured dupioni silk with a french lace overlay be? Plus, I love how the dress has the side slant pockets, which makes it a bit more stylish. The only pattern change I might make would be to make the neck line a bit lower - a deeper scoop. As for colour, it would likely be in the grey or champagne colour palettes. It would depend on the lace colour, but I wouldn't want the underlining to contrast too heavily - moreso just complement the lace (not match it). This would be a much more "wearable" dress, especially because it isn't a floor-length gown.